Ice Cream Topping Preferences by Trait

TraitGarnishTopping
Child orChildishSprinklesWhipped Cream
ActiveStrawberryChocolate Sauce
Art LoverOrange SlicesRaspberry Sauce
BroPeppermint StickChocolate Sauce
ClumsyFlowersSprinkles
Commitment IssuesPeppermint StickNuts
CreativeLeavesRaspberry Sauce
ErraticNutsNuts
EvilCinnamon StickRaspberry Sauce
FoodieFlowerRaspberry Sauce
GeekWaffleSprinkles
GeniusOrange SliceCoconut Shavings
GloomyNone hah.None
GluttonWaffleChocolate Sauce
GoodStrawberryWhipped Cream
GoofballBanana SlicesWhipped Cream
Hot HeadedPeppermint StickWhipped Cream
Loves the OutdoorsFlowerCoconut Shavings
LazySprinklesSprinkles
MaterialisticLeavesChocolate Sauce
MeanNutsCaramel Syrup
Music LoverBananaChocolate Sauce
NeatLeavesWhipped Cream
OutgoingOrange SliceCherry
PerfectionistWaffleCaramel Syrup
RomanticLeavesCherry
Self AssuredCinnamon StickCoconut Shavings
SlobSprinklesCaramel Syrup
SnobCinnamonRaspberry Sauce
source: Carl’s Sims 4 Guide: The Sims 4 Cool Kitchen Stuff Pack Review